Concert Review: The Whigs and The Hold Steady
CMM July 13th, 2010
Broke from my “don’t stay out past 9pm on a school night” rule and went downtown for The Whigs and The Hold Steady at The Square Room. It was great to be out and meet up with a grad school buddy, who in addition to being an entrepreneur, is also the keyboard player for local rock favorite The Dirty Guvnahs.
We came over to the show right about the time that The Whigs started their set. Unfortunately, the bass player had a personal issue and was unable to make this show. Since the band is a power trio (drums, bass, guitar/singer) they were seriously undermanned. The guitarist/singer did a few man-and-his-guitar songs that were pretty impressive, including a Sparklehorse cover. The drummer was selling merchandise in the back of the venue, but he joined for the last five songs. They recruited the tour manager for The Hold Steady on bass, and frankly, they sounded awesome. I’ve seen The Whigs a handful of times, and they never fail to impress. Even a man down, last night was no exception. These guys remain the standard for edgy power rock. They are great guys, very approachable, and just love their audience. There’s no fake angst, rocker fatigue, or ego with these guys. Just some great rock-n-roll. Check out this video for “Right Hand on My Heart”
When they finished and were leaving the stage, I told my buddy that I could have done with another hour of The Whigs. It’s the truth.
I wish I could say good things about The Hold Steady, and I’m sure they’re great, but the sound was so poorly mixed that it was painful. It was too loud (yes, that is possible), it was mixed poorly, and the band noise overpowered the singer. I mean you seriously couldn’t hear, let alone understand, the lead singer. As for the band, it just sounded like a bunch of noise and I don’t think I heard the keyboard after sound check. It was very disappointing because they seem like a great band, but they need to fire the sound guy. We left and walked down the street to another little hole-in-the-wall, where we chatted and listened to a local group.
Overall, The Whigs continue to rock… The Hold Steady may rock, but I have no way of knowing.




